UpGuard Alternative for
MSPs and SMBs
UpGuard has built one of the strongest security scanning platforms on the market. But their pricing and go-to-market are aimed at enterprise procurement teams, not MSPs managing 20-100 SMB clients. Here's the direct comparison.
What UpGuard Is Built For
UpGuard combines external attack surface monitoring with third-party vendor risk management. Enterprises use it to track their own exposure and rate the security of their vendor ecosystem.
UpGuard works well for:
- Enterprise security teams monitoring large vendor portfolios
- Organizations running formal third-party risk management programs
- Companies with dedicated security procurement staff
- Teams that need continuous monitoring, not on-demand scans
Where UpGuard creates friction for MSPs:
- No public pricing — every engagement requires a demo and sales conversation
- Enterprise contract model means annual commitments before you evaluate fit
- API is a paid add-on, not core product
- Minimum contract values typically disqualify small MSPs
- Onboarding involves implementation calls and scoping sessions
ComplianceLayer vs UpGuard
| Feature | ComplianceLayer | UpGuard |
|---|---|---|
| Starting price | $99/month | Contact sales |
| Self-serve signup | Yes | No (demo required) |
| Time to first scan | 5 minutes | Weeks |
| API access | Included on all plans | Paid add-on |
| External security modules | 16 live technical checks | External attack surface + vendor risk |
| Per-client scanning | Core use case | Possible but not primary design |
| White-label reports | Yes | No |
| Contract | Monthly, cancel anytime | Annual minimum |
| Free tier | 10 scans/month | No |
| Target market | MSPs, SMBs | Enterprise |
Where UpGuard Wins
Where ComplianceLayer Wins
Pricing Comparison
UpGuard
- No public pricing — demo required
- Annual contracts, enterprise minimum
- API: Paid add-on
ComplianceLayer ★ MSP Pricing
- Free: 10 scans/month, 1 domain, 7-day history
- Pro: $99/month — 1,000 scans, 50 domains, full API
- Enterprise: $499/month — 5,000 scans, 200 domains
- Monthly billing, no contracts
Common questions
Is ComplianceLayer as good as UpGuard?
For different use cases. UpGuard excels at continuous attack surface monitoring and vendor risk management at scale. ComplianceLayer is purpose-built for MSPs who need on-demand external security scanning across client domains. If you manage 20-100 client domains and need scans that produce actionable output, ComplianceLayer fits better.
Can I replace UpGuard with ComplianceLayer?
If you're using UpGuard for continuous enterprise monitoring, no — different tools for different jobs. If you signed up for UpGuard hoping to do MSP-style client assessments and found the fit awkward, ComplianceLayer was designed for that workflow.
Does ComplianceLayer scan automatically or do I run scans manually?
Both. You can trigger scans via the dashboard, via the API, or set up scheduled scans on Pro and Enterprise plans. Most MSPs combine scheduled weekly scans with on-demand scans before client meetings.
What security modules does ComplianceLayer check?
ComplianceLayer runs 16 external security modules per scan: DMARC record and policy, SPF record syntax and includes, DKIM key rotation, SSL certificate validity and cipher strength, TLS version, open port exposure, HTTP security headers (HSTS, CSP, X-Frame-Options, etc.), DNS configuration, CAA records, DNSSEC, domain reputation, and blacklist status.
Does ComplianceLayer work for cyber insurance pre-qualification?
Yes. The scan output directly maps to common underwriting questions. MSPs use ComplianceLayer reports to document client security posture before binding cyber insurance and to justify premium reductions after remediating findings.
Other comparisons
Start scanning your first
domain in 60 seconds.
No credit card. No sales call. No setup. Free tier is permanent.
All scans are passive and external — we never access your servers, install agents, or require credentials. View our security practices, live system status, or browse domain reports.